184 Comments

One thing is abundantly clear, the American people “can’t handle the truth”.

We scream about it beg for it and swear up and down that “all hell will break loose” until we get it.

So when the first President after FDR who has the integrity and humility to gives it to us, we choke. He’s labeled a “weakling” and a freak not because he’s wrong but because we simply can’t look inward and accept the truth we claim we need.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023·edited Feb 24, 2023

Well said, Bob. Americans' (and other people's) proneness to pathological projection is so very disappointing--and incredibly harmful.

Expand full comment

I wish you mentioned that Ronald Regan --aka the republicans capitalized on the forces of the dark soul for power.

That Regan even interfered with the hostages coming home, so like a movie character he could be the hero.

Republicans then were willing to destroy what was good, what was truth for power.

IT. WAS . ALL. A. LIE.

When is this corruption going to be called out???

I was coming into grad school when he gave that speech. I remember every part of it and thinking, there is the mirror and citizens of the US are going to break it.

Expand full comment

Superb post, Karen! I too was going to mention that utterly corrupt, rotten "October Surprise" enacted by the Reagan team -- secretly bribing Iran's ayatollah regime to delay release of the American hostages until after the Nov. presidential election in USA.

And then of course there was Reagan's ridiculous and short-sighted first order of his administration: take down the solar panels off the White House that Pres. Carter had presciently installed. We might already have 50 or 80% of our nation's energy coming from the sun had Carter's vision not been reversed.

Expand full comment

Ditto. I posted before reading the comments.

Expand full comment

Couldn’t agree more!

Expand full comment

It’s so interesting that Reagan is credited with restoring the confidence of America as he lied to its citizens while beginning the astounding transfer of wealth from the middle class up to the 1%.

“In 2021, the ratio of CEO-to-typical-worker compensation was 399-to-1 under the realized measure of CEO pay; that is up from 366-to-1 in 2020 and a big increase from 20-to-1 in 1965 and 59-to-1 in 1989.”

https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-pay-in-2021/

Expand full comment

Not just interesting. Horrifying.

Expand full comment

I'll read it, alright. I won't like it. But I'll read it. I think that I read, some years ago, that the CEO's in the largest companies in Japan were not allowed to earn more than 20 X the lowest paid employee. Can you imagine how wonderful that would be, here?! It would certainly raise wages on the lowest paying jobs!

Expand full comment

He opened the flood gates to grifting and corruption.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the excellent insights in this comment thread!! I should have added this too--go to the 12.17 mark if you only have a minute--but the entire 10 minutes is astounding. "Because he was a decent human being and they weren't having any of that" https://www.cnn.com/videos/tv/2022/05/04/amanpour-schaeffer-abortion-scotus-roe.cnn

Expand full comment

Brilliant simile. We hate being shown for the nation of “Dorian Greys” that we are.

Expand full comment

@Martha Hoag .. +1.. Brilliant, spot on! .. "Oscar Wilde"

Expand full comment

Image is really scary and right on!

Expand full comment

Reagan's initial response to the HIV crisis was terribly irresponsible and made things worse especially with his "christian" hangers on like Ralph Reed and Jerry Falwell. Additionally we mustn't forget Iran Contra, and the ridiculousness of trickle down economics.

Expand full comment

Agreed but this was not about Reagan

Expand full comment

You're absolutely right. My comment was made in response to a thread regarding Reagan.

Expand full comment

I know that’s what bothered me. This was not about him and the comments were illfounded

Expand full comment

Not the right place for it.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Of which Don the Con was the dumpster.

Expand full comment

Thank you for the positive words on President Carter and sharing his speech to the Nation. I was a tween at the time and recall how my late parents thought the world of him, irregardless of what the neighbors thought. He has shown what true dignity is. He left office with the intention of helping his fellow American, and followed through. Unlike some of the presidents who followed in the Republican Party.

Expand full comment

"He has shown what true dignity is." Dignity! Thank you, Kevin, for your poignant expression of respect and gratitude for Jimmy Carter.

Expand full comment

Regardless. Ir-regardless is not a word, as it makes a double negative. Sorry, English is my second language, with it’s complex rules- but expression with language is all we have in this format…..

Expand full comment

Thanks for staying with the subject. Your English lesson was misplaced and rather rude. It has nothing to do with this essay or the message Steve was trying to bring forward.

Expand full comment

Run! It's the Language Fuzz!!

Expand full comment

(I had the same thought. Like you, I can't just gloss over grammatical errors in my mind. Perhaps not mentioning it in this context was not the time? I'm certainly not judging you.)

Expand full comment

Irregardless, That’s what I was taught in school, as a word. It even came up in spellcheck.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Martha said that English is her second language. I think that as a result she listens very carefully to every word that's said in English and is very sensitive to the sounds. I don't believe that her intention was to be rude. Just IMHO.

Expand full comment
Feb 25, 2023·edited Feb 25, 2023

Kevin, or the democrat presidents Clinton and even Obama. There is always a price tag attached to those two men's speeches etc. Obama could never afford the kind of house he lives in now, nor Clinton either. I'm not against either, but the kind of "helping" post presidency that Carter participated in is a very far cry from the kind of helping the other two have done. Carter stands apart from both republicans and democrats in a way that is worth noting beyond politics.

Expand full comment

Hear, hear. I had the privilege of meeting and working with President Carter on Habitat for Humanity builds in Georgia and Baja California. I was on assignment from my magazine to write about HFH. He was unlike any other politician I had ever covered. Carter was quiet, focused, and spoke only about the importance of the mission of building homes, a mission that totally absorbed him, in serious tones. No glad-handing. No glittering turns of phrase. No politicking or PR smiles. He was in that moment a quiet and determined carpenter and, man, that was impressive.

Expand full comment

@JB .. +1. .. BIG time "impressive" ...

Expand full comment

The measure of a person is what they have done and what they leave as a legacy. What we see with President Carter is one faithful to his God, faithful to his wife and family, faithful to his Country and his Oath of Office. What he did with his life after his term in office is remarkable for its focus on the good of the world and those around him. Leadership by example. May that Servant Leadership stay with us.

Expand full comment

Beautiful history on President Carter.

God bless President Jimmy Carter and FL Rosalyn.

Expand full comment

M the night that Jimmy Carter lost the election, I was caring for the grandchildren of Donald Regan. The Regans had gathered in anticipation of a Reagan win, and so I needed to cry privately. Within hours, I got the word to expect Secret Service presence in anticipation of Don Regans return. Of course there was great jubilation because they knew Regan had been selected to become Secy of State. Being gracious in my grief was not easy. I went to my room and wrote my grief out in a letter to Jimmy Carter. Amazingly, he replied. I cried then and I cry today reading this article.

Expand full comment

I have sent Christmas cards to the Carters for years. I donated small amounts to the Carter Foundation and received my first Christmas card from them. The one I received this year was a beautiful painting done by Mr Carter. I have always kept them over the years but lost all of them in Hurricane Harvey in 2017 and again in Imelda in 2019. I have the ones received since then.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

I have Christmas cards from the Carter Center too. His paintings are beautiful and I had no idea he was so talented an artist. Kept all mine too. Love them! I wonder if you can write to the Carter center and get copies. So sorry you endured losses from two hurricanes and so close together…

Expand full comment

I have always felt so happy receiving their Christmas cards every year, as well.

Expand full comment

What is shame that you lost your cards and I suspect more than that in the hurricanes! So glad that you have a few of them for remembrances! Happy to meet a fellow Carter admirer!

Expand full comment

It appears to me that President Carter perceived the future. These words from his speech have manifested: “We are at a turning point in our history. There are two paths to choose. One is a path I've warned about tonight, the path that leads to fragmentation and self-interest. Down that road lies a mistaken idea of freedom, the right to grasp for ourselves some advantage over others. That path would be one of constant conflict between narrow interests ending in chaos and immobility. It is a certain route to failure.” Prophetic? Possibly. He was powerless to the wheel of fortune that was turning. Though he tried to hold it back that wheel rolled over him and here we are today at the end of that path with the help of his successor President Reagan, and the other conservatives who followed caring only about $$$$$$$$$$$

Expand full comment

What an excellent and true quote, one that perfectly reflects what’s happening now.

Expand full comment

I had the same thought: the he was a prophet. One definition of "prophet" is "a prophet is someone chosen by God to speak for God". Given the depth of his spirituality, I can't help wondering...

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

Godspeed, indeed. President Carter can depart this mortal coil knowing he gave his entire life to the service of others over service of self. He was the first POTUS I ever supported as my political awareness came into being as a 7 year old watching the Nixon debacle & hearing the heated political discussions at the dinner table & at holiday gatherings. My father was the lone Republican of the group back in those days and he typified the men of his generation on whom the character Archie Bunker was based. We moved to a new house in 1972, & the mortgage rate was 12%. I gave my first “political speech” at age 8 supporting Jimmy Carter, the peanut farmer from Georgia. Americans were pissed when Carter told us to “put on a sweater” rather than raise the heat. There were long lines to buy gas. Then, our chickens came home to roost in Iran & the hostage crisis foreclosed any hope of a 2nd term for Carter. He was in a no-win situation.

If I were Catholic, I would put Carter up for sainthood.

Expand full comment

The parallel content of our comments are remarkable!

Expand full comment

It was the perfect analysis of a great human being who led us from two significant positions:

1. As the elected and sworn in President of our nation where his accomplishments were minimal for many reasons most of which were not by his faults.

2. He led the American peoples, of all colors, races and religions, by his very strong human characteristics. This leadership is what defines him and what we need even more at this time in our history.

God bless you Jimmy Carter and "Peace be with you"!

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

And managed to bring Sadat and Begin together for The Camp David Accords.

Expand full comment

Thank you, thank you, thank you for this, Steve. For a “political consultant,” you can sure write! This was eloquent, heartfelt and powerful.

My first vote as a 19 year in 1972 was for Richard Nixon. I grew up a Baptist in a small Texas town. It was very similar in size to Plains, Georgia where the Baptist Jimmy Carter grew up. I guess as a very young person I thought that voting for Nixon was the “conservative” vote. I came to regret it almost immediately.

I voted for Jimmy Carter twice, in both 1976 and yes 1980 against the conservative savior, Ronald Reagan. I have never regretted those votes in the almost 50 years since.

I remembered little of that “terrible” speech of his. Thanks for sharing it. It was both good and right. As a Christian, he embodies what a Christ follower should look like to as great a degree as any human being can.

The absolute moral bankruptcy of the main evangelical community in America today breaks my heart and brings shame and dishonor on our faith.

Thank you for shining a light so beautifully on the life and legacy of Jimmy Carter.

Expand full comment
author

Rick,

Check out my post tomorrow. I'll reveal a thing or two about my writing :-)

Steve

Expand full comment

Than you for your voice! We need it and other like it desperately.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

One of the many polar contrasts between this epic address and DJT's nomination acceptance speech and his inaugural one is that James Earl Carter spoke from his heart out of love for every American and institution of government, from a belief that our nation can be saved by the people. No self-serving motive. No attempt to manipulate. Thank you Mr. President. May your words resonate at this very challenging time... may they be heard and heeded.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023·edited Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

As I ponder President Carter's death and his service to America, I am hopeful that all of these tributes will be played on all media, including this speech. As I imagine it, this will give our country the choice to reflect on how little has changed since then and ignite the spark for us to unite in a clarifying mission to work together. In God's timing, may it be Jimmy Carter's final humanitarian hug to the world.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

This speech should be printed up and distributed in his memory. I was too young to recall this speech but understand fully what this gentle & intelligent human was trying to convey. In a way, this message also contains our salvation as a nation: look inside, is consumption making us happy? What outside of Christian nationalism can help provide a sense of unification for our multi-cultural society? What are each one of us actually doing to show up and participate in civic life? What is humility and how can that help us all grow as people and as citizens?

Just as Queen Elizabeth II provided a sort of moral & reassuring ballast to the world, so too has President Carter served as that moral & reassuring force in my own life.

There are wonderful videos on YouTube of him walking the aisles of commercial airliners smiling and shaking hands with what appear to be absolutely delighted passengers. Well worth looking up for a smile.

Expand full comment

Yes, he was a kind, humble, and loving person. What other (former) President would take the time and energy to greet all of the passengers on a commercial flight? All the more so because he was an introvert.

Expand full comment

It’s a beautiful dream. 💙

Expand full comment

Jimmy Carter ran his life's race well. He tried to govern according to his faith. He loved God and his neighbor, in all the places where he found them. He was a voice for peace and for the ordinary person. He spoke the truth as he understood it to be. I am proud to have voted for him twice. May your family hear the angels sing your welcome home song.

Expand full comment

I also voted for him twice.

Expand full comment

So did I.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

What an interesting response in your college. Well done.

Expand full comment
deletedFeb 24, 2023·edited Feb 24, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

And there you have it. The “trick” you speak of is Reagan’s version of the psychological war on truth. It has been sharpened into a lethal weapon by the far right to divide us.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

Thank you Steve for this beautiful piece about Jimmy Carter. It made me weep, as your words often do. This time, I wept for our poor country and the intensification of all of the pain and problems that Mr. Carter spoke of so eloquently and lovingly all those years ago and yet, we are still in pain and it only gets worse. He is a remarkable, gifted man; a truly spiritual man and we shall not see his likes again.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023Liked by Steve S

Thank you, Steve, for this moving tribute to a great statesman and finer human.

My first introduction to politics was the Carter campaign. My mother, who just passed, was a volunteer for President Carter’s campaign. She was also a faithful poll worker for decades. I think of her every time I hear the terrible stories of attacks on every day Americans who simply want to do their civic duty. President Carter inspired her and my family to serve and try to improve this world. One of my priceless possessions is a photograph of mom holding my younger sister, while President Jimmy Carter smiles that fantastic smile. Godspeed and blessings, Mr. President. Our nation didn’t deserve you.

Expand full comment

Bless your Mom. Cherish the memories. ♥️

Expand full comment

I wanted to have an insightful response - but literally, I just cried. I have always been a Jimmy Carter (fan just doesn’t sound right!) - Reader. I own and re-read all his books.

My parents and I share his birthday - it is one of the most common birthdays on earth - it means you were conceived between Christmas and New Year’s. Because of that - our whole family became committed to his campaign, Presidency, and supported the work of Habitat for Humanity and the Carter Center.

His age, illness, and ultimately his passing have me grieving as if I am losing my Parents again.

This man was always ahead of our time. There are human “touchstones” (my family call it our “List”) - people whose mere presence make the World better: The Dalai Lama, Nelson Mandela, Ruth Bader-Ginsburg, George Harrison…. When these people pass, the World is made darker, somehow. New people may rise up to fill the gaps, but more often than not- the World is just less….

May his name be a Blessing.

Expand full comment