Discussion about this post

User's avatar
enoonmai enoonmai's avatar

Justice Roberts wrote the horrendous Citizens United and Shelby decisions, equating free speech with money and gutting the Voting Rights Act, respectively. Roberts' antipathy to voting rights was molded by Rehnquist, and he is impervious to the error of his ways. He was in the Dobbs majority. What's to respect? Also, in what way was Alito broken by his confirmation hearings? His mother knew he'd vote to overturn Roe. She told the press at the time; they quoted her. And I am willing to accept you were privy to considerable inside information, but from the outside, it seems Republicans didn't need any help in tanking the Miers nomination. This Democrat here doesn't know whether she was qualified for the high court, but in retrospect, I sure wish she were there instead of Alito.

Expand full comment
JennSH from NC's avatar

After what happened to Merrick Garland's nomination when Antonin Scalia died, I have to wonder if it would have mattered if Justice Ginsburg had resigned. Some Republicans spoke about denying a Democratic president a Supreme Court nominee for that person's entire term. Nasty Moscow Mitch has gamed the antiquated system we have and revealed its flaws by breaking that system.

Expand full comment
89 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?