36 Comments
User's avatar
Carol Gamm's avatar

Thank you.

Rich W's avatar

One of the best synopsis of our fraught and often mistold origin story. It would be wonderful to acknowledge the cruelty, correct the oversights and failings as we repair and build upon what was nobly started two hundred and fifty years ago.

Husaria's avatar

"....In order to form a more perfect Union....."

True then. True now.

Our founders knew that we would always be a work in progress. They also knew we would make mistakes along the way.

Billie Larson's avatar

Yes, but they never imagined TRUMP!

Husaria's avatar

I think they did but........they didn't factor in the toadies that are being co-dependent in ruining our nation.

Invoke the 25th, Congress. If not now then when?

Billie Larson's avatar

Regret not including U.S. Senators, House Members, State, County and Local eleted officials, MAGA, people who voted for him. -- You want more? ....... Trump is not only a person, the word will one day replace FUCK in the dictionary.

Husaria's avatar

When people talk about evil, they bring up Hitler. I agree that in the future we will say Trump instead.

Dick Montagne's avatar

There are forks in every road, if you discover that you don’t like where you are headed, you take the next fork, and presto you’re on a different road. 🙏

Thomas Locatell's avatar

What can be offered before this magnificent panorama that Steve has crafted? It's through the lens of art that I will make my humble attempt.

The whole is greater than the sum of the parts. Each one of us is a brushstroke in a painting, whether a blade of grass, an oak tree or the shadow that it casts, we add our own contribution. E Pluribs Unum.

Robbie Roberts's avatar

Steve, this work of yours — whether by Warning or SAM or Cause — is invaluable. I try to put it in front of my family, friends and acquaintances who would otherwise never give our complex American journey a thought because today leads to tomorrow. But today was 400 years in the making, that’s 400 years of wisdom, and as our poetic scribe and cometized prophet Mr. Twain made sure we knew, it rhymes and it rhymes and it rhymes. Keep it coming!

Steve Schmidt's avatar

Thank you!

Steve

Robbie Roberts's avatar

And thank you, Steve. Your work, energy and commitment keep me toiling and engaged.

Mo Khan's avatar

Eloquent !!!

Thank you for the history and motivation!

Douglas Mackay's avatar

I truly am moved by these posts that recount our history from its first tentative yet confident beginnings. It’s inspiring to know that a functioning and prosperous society evolved from people with little shared values and interests who struggled together to make the most of their situation. That pattern is repeated throughout history, here and elsewhere. Humanity, even all animal life, resurrects itself constantly. If only it could do so more quickly, like immediately, here in the grand ol’ USA. Soon enough gives me no pleasure but, as we have come to believe, hope springs eternal. Addendum: …and comes from effort.

JA's avatar
Mar 22Edited

Steve: That message is exquisite! Thanks for being who you are and sharing with WE the People. Keep them coming since we need to strengthen ourselves! We are in this together.

David Selditz's avatar

As one who is cautiously optimistic, I embrace the mistakes and progress over 250 years. We will come out of this insane disruption with a reset of a more civil society. I thoroughly enjoyed this post and look forward to the series. It's history at its best.

Joe C's avatar

Excellent history lesson! Thanks.

Barking Justice Media's avatar

Steve-

What strikes me about the Compact is the condition under which it was signed. It seems that it was not inspiration, but necessity. They had no legal standing where they landed. The Virginia charter was worthless.

41 men wrote their own authority into existence because the alternative was no authority at all.

Roosevelt understood this when he came to Provincetown in 1907: the Compact wasn't a founding document, it was a survival mechanism that became one.

Does that distinction matter to how we invoke it now?

-Mika

Anthony j. Santo's avatar

"They built a new civilization from the wilderness that would become the United States."

"The world that John Winthrop envisioned was never fulfilled, but its possibilities have endured.."

Steve Schmidt

The Pilgrims were not perfect, far from it. They were intolerant, racist, and narrow-minded but nonetheless they did hope to build their idea of a perfect society. Two quotes from our Dear Leader are illustrious of how far we have fallen from any form of decency or idealism:

"....when I heard President Donald Trump's remark this weekend that after "totally demolishing" Iran's Kharg Island, the United States "may hit a few more times just for fun," I was taken aback

David L. Nevins

"Trump posted on social media about Mueller's death: "Robert Mueller just died. Good, I'm glad he is dead. He can no longer hurt innocent people.

The Associated Press by Eric Tucker

Husaria's avatar

If you listen close enough you can hear John Winthrop, Cotton Mather, John Standish spinning in their graves.

Yes, they were far from perfect. In some cases they were crazy. Looking at you Cotton. But, they were at least decent human beings that understood pain, suffering and death.

Thomas Locatell's avatar

Even the shadows make their own contribution. Without light they would not exist.

CH's avatar

Let us assure that the people who are responsible for our current suffering are held accountable..

Ken Davies's avatar

Hypocrisy was built into the American Republic from the start, but some of your founding fathers at least recognised that fact, perhaps every advanced polity has to go through something like a Trump the Athenian democracy, the Roman republic, Britain and France, but at least then there weren’t nuclear weapons in the equation.then even if there were eschatological prophecies.

Michel Moyse's avatar

Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. We The People. These represent aspirations for all of humanity. These aspirations are founded on the notion that fundamentally we're all equal. Not first and foremost citizens of any nation - whether American or other. It's high time we began to see ourselves united in these aspirations. Identifications with any country, short of defining relative space and time, should give way to a larger and deeper understanding that we're all 'citizens' of the world. Hence the importance of conduct that invites unity, trust, love, respect, tolerance, good-will. This, as I see it, is the crafting of a "new age" in our time.

Jean A. Austin-Long's avatar

Our forefathers warned about a Trump sort of man who would slip in and try to take us down, and here he is. Now the fight begins in real time.

Cecile Blankenhorn's avatar

Steve, I have not been receiving emails from you for at least the past several weeks even though I am a paid subscriber. Please help, cblankenhorn23@gmail.com

Thomas Locatell's avatar

Have you tried your spam folder. I have not had that problem, that I know of. I am a stranger in the land of tech, that's all I got.